Why are you seeing adverts on our website for the first time? Click here to learn more.
Keep our news free from paywalls by making a donation to support our work!
Notes from Poland is run by a small editorial team and is published by an independent, non-profit foundation that is funded through donations from our readers. We cannot do what we do without your support.
Poland’s rule-of-law crisis has taken another twist, after the Supreme Court (SN) issued a resolution effectively opposing the government’s position towards another top court, the Constitutional Tribunal (TK), and endorsing that of opposition-aligned President Karol Nawrocki.
The SN found that TK rulings are only valid if issued by judges the president has sworn in and that they take effect even if the government refuses to publish them. Nawrocki has refused to swear in fivfe TK judges, while the government has refused to publish 85 previous TK rulings.
However, the government’s justice minister argues that the new SN resolution is itself invalid because it was issued by judges who were appointed unlawfully.
Połączone izby Sądu Najwyższego o wyrokach Trybunału Konstytucyjnego jako podstawie wznowienia postępowaniahttps://t.co/DzgL6aDTGK pic.twitter.com/GpiGbWMvNn
— SÄ…d Najwyższy (@SN_RP_) November 18, 2026
On Wednesday, the SN issued a resolution in response to questions over the validity of rulings issued by the TK.
It found, among other things, that a valid TK ruling can only be issued by a panel of judges who, after being elected to the tribunal by parliament, have “taken an oath before the president, that is, in his presence”.
Those latter words relate to a key dispute that has arisen around the TK. The government’s majority in parliament has this year chosen eight new TK judges, who would now form the majority on the 15-seat tribunal.
However, Nawrocki has refused to receive the oath of five of those judges, citing concerns over the method of their appointment or their qualifications.
Those five judges have instead arranged their own swearing-in ceremonies before a notary and then forwarded their oaths to the presidential chancellery. They and the government argue that this meets the requirement for them to take up their seats.
However, Nawrocki and the TK’s chief justice, Bogdan ÅšwiÄ™czkowski, who was appointed under the former government, reject that position and say that the judges cannot take up their seats on the court until the president receives their oath in person. The Supreme Court has now effectively endorsed their stance.
Meanwhile, the SN also addressed another contentious issue. Since March 2024, the current government – a coalition ranging from left to centre right led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk – has refused to publish any of the 85 TK rulings issued in that time.
That is because, under the former national-conservative Law and Justice (PiS) government, three judges were unlawfully appointed to the TK.
The current government argues that TK rulings only take force when published in the official Journal of Laws. Indeed, so did the former PiS government when, in 2016, it refused to publish TK rulings that contradicted its judicial policies. However, the SN has now deemed that valid TK rulings enter force even if not published.
“In a situation where the body responsible for publishing TK rulings fails to fulfil this obligation…these abuses by the executive power cannot affect the universally binding force of TK rulings,” said SN judge Aleksander StÄ™pkowski, quoted by the Dziennik Gazeta Prawna daily.
However, the validity of the SN’s resolution is itself contested as it was issued by judges whose own status is questioned.
That is because they were appointed to the court through the National Council of the Judiciary (KRS) after it was overhauled by PiS in a manner that brought it under political control and rendered it invalid, according to Polish and European court rulings.
The current government has generally rejected decisions issued by such “neo-judges”, as it calls them. And that position was reiterated on Thursday by justice minister Waldemar Å»urek, who wrote that “the neo-judges in the Supreme Court have adopted a so-called resolution”
“Any decision issued with the participation of even one person appointed through the politicised National Council of the Judiciary after 2017 is a non-existent judgement,” he added.
Neosędziowie w Sądzie Najwyższym podjęli nibyuchwałę połączonych trzech izb (III CZP 41/26), uznając, że nieopublikowane rozstrzygnięcia Trybunału Konstytucyjnego mają moc powszechnie obowiązującą, a za wyrok TK można uznać tylko taki wydany przez osoby, które złożyły ślubowanie…
— Waldemar Å»urek (@w_zurek) November 18, 2026
The SN’s resolution comes as the TK itself is embroiled in a crisis. At the end of October, the eight new TK judges chosen by parliament this year took control of the tribunal and announced that its chief justice, ÅšwiÄ™czkowski, had been suspended for failing to fulfil his duties.
ÅšwiÄ™czkowski, supported by Nawrocki and the SN’s chief justice, Zbigniew KapiÅ„ski (also a “neo-judge”), has rejected that move as an illegal “coup d’état” and claims he is still in charge of the tribunal. However, police have prevented him from entering the building.
On Wednesday, just as the SN was issuing its resolution, the eight government-backed TK judges announced that they had lifted ÅšwiÄ™czkowski’s immunity from prosecution at the request of Å»urek.

Notes from Poland is run by a small editorial team and published by an independent, non-profit foundation that is funded through donations from our readers. We cannot do what we do without your support.
Main image credit: tomislav medak/Flickr (under CC BY 2.0)

Daniel Tilles is editor-in-chief of Notes from Poland. He has written on Polish affairs for a wide range of publications, including Foreign Policy, POLITICO Europe, EUobserver and Dziennik Gazeta Prawna.


















