This recent article contains some pretty brazen duplicity, even by the standards of the Daily Mail.
The newspaper has been at the forefront of a campaign by the British right-wing tabloid press over the last few years to portray immigrants from new EU countries – particularly Poles, who make up the largest group – as ‘benefit tourists’, coming to Britain not to work but to claim social welfare. (The Daily Express and the Sun also deserve special mention, the latter of which rather amusingly had to admit its dishonesty.) Continue reading
By Daniel Tilles
By apparently agreeing to David Cameron’s proposal to restrict benefits for EU migrants in the UK, Poland’s government has made a dramatic reversal on its earlier declarations that it would never accept such discrimination against Polish citizens. Daniel Tilles asks whether this U-turn is the result of a pragmatic compromise or if, instead, the ruling Law and Justice (PiS) party has used the rights of its countrymen as bargaining chip to gain concessions from the British that advance its own political agenda.
As I’ve written in these pages previously, a particular concern in Britain stemming from the unprecedented wave of immigration during the last decade has been over ‘benefit tourism’: the idea that some migrants are coming not to work, but to take advantage of the country’s generous welfare system. Such accusations have been directed in particular against Poles, who make up the largest group among recent European immigrants and who, as EU citizens, are legally entitled to receive benefits on the same basis as British natives. Continue reading
A notable feature of the growing anti-immigration rhetoric in British political discourse in recent years has been the specific criticism directed against Poles. Prime Minister David Cameron, in his campaign against the alleged exploitation of the UK’s social-welfare system by immigrants, has explicitly used Poles to personify the problem. The leader of the main opposition party, Ed Miliband (ironically himself the son of emigrants from Poland), has claimed that ‘Polish immigration in particular’ is ‘driving down living standards’ for British people. Jack Straw, who was foreign secretary from 2001-2006, recently admitted that the decision his government made to allow unlimited immigration from ‘states like Poland’ was a ‘spectacular mistake’. Continue reading
Znaczącą cechą coraz bardziej popularnej retoryki antyimigracyjnej w brytyjskim dyskursie politycznym jest ostatnimi laty wyraźna krytyka skierowana przeciwko Polakom. W swojej kampanii przeciw rzekomemu wykorzystywaniu systemu socjalnego przez imigrantów, Premier David Cameron użył przykładu Polaków jako uosobienia problemu. Lider głównej partii opozycyjnej, Ed Miliband (jak na ironię sam będący synem emigrantów z Polski), stwierdził, że „polska imigracja w szczególności (…) obniża standard życia Brytyjczyków”. Jack Straw, minister spraw zagranicznych w latach 2001-2006, ostatnio przyznał, że decyzja jego rządu by pozwolić na nieograniczoną imigrację „z krajów takich, jak Polska” była „spektakularnym błędem”.